Your mattress is a big investment, and naturally, you want to keep it in tip-top shape for as long as possible. That’s where a high-quality mattress protector comes in! It’s not just about guarding against spills; a good protector can fend off allergens, dust mites, and even help regulate your sleep temperature, ensuring a cleaner, healthier, and more comfortable night’s rest. When it comes to reliable mattress protection, Protect-A-Bed mattress protectors are often the first name that comes to mind, known for their innovative designs and durable materials.
We’ve scoured the market to bring you a comprehensive review of the top 5 mattress protectors that stand out, focusing heavily on Protect-A-Bed’s popular offerings and including one highly-rated alternative that delivers exceptional value. Let’s dive in and find the perfect shield for your bed!
Why Invest in a Mattress Protector?
Before we jump into the reviews, let’s quickly recap why a mattress protector is an absolute bedding essential:
- Spill and Stain Protection: Accidents happen. A waterproof barrier saves your mattress from coffee, juice, pet accidents, or even just perspiration.
- Allergen and Dust Mite Defense: Many protectors create a physical barrier against common allergens like dust mites, pet dander, and pollen, which can significantly improve air quality and help those with allergies or asthma.
- Extend Mattress Lifespan: By keeping your mattress clean and dry, a protector helps maintain its structural integrity and hygiene, prolonging its life.
- Hygiene and Cleanliness: It’s much easier to wash a mattress protector than to clean an entire mattress, ensuring a consistently fresh sleeping surface.
- Comfort Enhancement: Some protectors offer additional padding, cooling properties, or a softer sleep surface, adding to your overall comfort.
Our Top 5 Mattress Protectors Reviewed
Here are our top picks, designed to help you protect a bed mattress protectors and ensure a great night’s sleep.
Protect-A-Bed Premium Cotton-Terry Mattress Protector (Fitted Style)
This classic from Protect-A-Bed is a fan favorite for good reason. It combines the soft, absorbent comfort of a cotton-terry surface with the renowned waterproof “Miracle Membrane” backing, giving you reliable protection without sacrificing breathability. It’s designed to fit like a fitted sheet, making it easy to put on and take off, and it won’t change the feel of your mattress. If you’re looking for straightforward, effective, and comfortable mattress protection, this is a solid go-to.
Key Features:
– FITS MOST MATTRESSES: 5-sided fitted-sheet style stretches to fit mattresses 9 – 14 inches in depth.
– WATERPROOF: Miracle Membrane backing extends the life of the mattress by blocking accidents, incontinence, perspiration, spills and stains.
– BREATHABLE BARRIER FABRIC: Maximum air permeability for a cool night’s sleep.
– SOFT & NOISELESS: Designed for all types of mattresses including memory foam, hybrid, latex or innerspring. It stays smooth and neat, so your mattress will feel as quiet and comfy as before the cover was applied.
– Machine Washable
Pros:
– Soft and comfortable cotton-terry surface.
– Effective waterproof barrier against all liquids.
– Breathable design prevents overheating.
– Quiet and doesn’t crinkle under sheets.
– Easy to install and machine washable for convenience.
Cons:
– Only protects the top and sides (5-sided).
– May not fit extremely deep mattresses (over 14 inches).
User Impressions:
Customers consistently praise this protector for its soft feel, genuine waterproof capability, and lack of noise. Many appreciate how it doesn’t alter the comfort of their mattress and stands up well to repeated washing. It’s often recommended for everyday spill protection and maintaining mattress hygiene.
Protect-A-Bed Premium Cotton-Terry Mattress Encasement (AllerZip Smooth)
For those seeking the ultimate in comprehensive protection, the Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Encasement is a game-changer. Unlike a fitted protector, an encasement fully zips around your entire mattress, offering 6-sided waterproof and allergen protection. This total coverage solution is perfect for individuals with severe allergies, asthma, or anyone wanting to create the healthiest possible sleep environment by completely sealing off their mattress from dust mites, bed bugs, and allergens.
Key Features:
– The AllerZip Smooth Mattress or Box Spring Encasement keeps your sleeping area for a healthy night’s rest.
– Total coverage solution wraps your mattress with 6-sides of waterproof Miracle Membrane protection, extending the life of your mattress.
– The AllerZip barrier promotes a healthy sleep environment.
– Easy to Wash and Use: Machine washable in warm or hot water; tumble dry low.
Pros:
– 6-sided total protection against liquids, allergens, and bed bugs.
– Creates a completely sealed, healthy sleep environment.
– Extends mattress lifespan significantly by preventing all intrusion.
– Machine washable and easy to maintain.
– Smooth surface won’t change mattress feel.
Cons:
– More effort to install due to full encasement design.
– May feel slightly warmer than a 5-sided protector for some users, though it’s still breathable.
User Impressions:
Reviewers highlight the peace of mind this encasement provides, especially for allergy sufferers. The full zipper closure and robust material are frequently mentioned as strong points. Many feel it’s a worthwhile investment for safeguarding their mattress comprehensively and improving their sleep quality.
Protect-A-Bed Mattress Protector – Waterproof, Breathable, TENCEL Lyocell Fabric Top
Elevate your sleep experience with this luxurious Protect-A-Bed mattress protector featuring a TENCEL Lyocell fabric top. TENCEL is known for its incredible softness, breathability, and moisture-wicking properties, making it an excellent choice for a comfortable and cool night’s sleep. Combined with the reliable waterproof barrier and antimicrobial features, this protector offers a premium blend of protection, comfort, and hygiene, especially for those with sensitive skin or who tend to sleep warm.
Key Features:
– Ultimate Mattress Protection: Waterproof barrier guards against spills, stains, allergens, and dust mites.
– TENCEL Lyocell Fabric Top: Soft, breathable, and ultra-quiet for a comfortable night’s sleep.
– Antimicrobial & Hypoallergenic: Helps reduce odor and allergen buildup for a cleaner sleeping environment.
– Secure Fit: Designed to stretch and fit deep mattresses snugly, without bunching or shifting.
– Two Sizes Available: Choose from Queen or King to fit your bed perfectly.
Pros:
– Ultra-soft and smooth TENCEL surface for enhanced comfort.
– Highly breathable and moisture-wicking, ideal for temperature regulation.
– Antimicrobial properties help keep your mattress fresh and odor-free.
– Waterproof and hypoallergenic for comprehensive protection.
– Stretchy design ensures a snug fit on deep mattresses.
Cons:
– Limited size options (only Queen or King listed).
– A higher price point compared to basic cotton-terry protectors.
User Impressions:
Users rave about the exceptional softness and cool feel of the TENCEL fabric. Many commend its ability to stay quiet and not crinkle, even with movement. The antimicrobial feature is also a plus for maintaining freshness. It’s often chosen by those seeking a more luxurious feel alongside robust protection.
Cooling Charcoal Infused Mattress Protector, Protect-A-Bed
For hot sleepers, the Cooling Charcoal Infused Mattress Protector from Protect-A-Bed is a dream come true. This innovative protector integrates cooling fibers and charcoal, which actively work to pull heat away from your body throughout the night, ensuring a more comfortable sleep temperature. Its ultra-thin and flexible design provides waterproof protection without adding bulk or noise, making it perfect for maintaining the feel of your mattress while staying cool and protected.
Key Features:
– ULTRA-THIN DESIGN: Very thin, ultra-light, flexible, smooth and quiet fabric encourages the passage of moisture and air, while delivering complete waterproof mattress protection.
– 5-SIDED: Well-designed fitted-sheet style protector with 4-way stretch to fit mattresses that are 11 – 18 inches in depth.
– COOLING CHARCOAL: The unique combination of cooling fibers is developed to reduce sleep temperatures. It actively pulls heat away from sleepers throughout the night. Additionally, those with sensitive skin and needing something gentle, this smooth surface is more resistant to wear and tear, and pilling than cotton.
– EASY TO WASH AND USE: Machine washable with laundry detergents that do not contain bleach or bleach alternatives and then simply tumble dry on low heat with bed sheets, towels or other clothing. Please do not dry clean, iron, or bleach.
– NOISELESS & BREATHABLE: This unique design allows for a noiseless healthy sleep environment and maximum air permeability.
– MIRACLE MEMBRANE: Waterproof barrier (polyurethane inside lining) along with a high quality raised jacquard lyocell from tencel top surface will extend the life of your mattress by blocking accidents, spills and stains. It will also protect you from allergens that may lurk in your mattress, including mold, mildew, pet dander, and pollen.
Pros:
– Excellent cooling properties for hot sleepers.
– Ultra-thin and flexible, preserving mattress feel.
– Activated charcoal helps with odor absorption and skin gentleness.
– Comprehensive 5-sided waterproof and allergen protection.
– Fits a wide range of mattress depths (11-18 inches).
– Durable and resistant to wear and pilling.
Cons:
– Specific washing instructions (no bleach) require careful attention.
– May be a premium option compared to standard protectors.
User Impressions:
Customers frequently comment on the noticeable cooling effect and the soft, smooth feel of this protector. Hot sleepers find it particularly effective in maintaining a comfortable temperature. Its quiet nature and easy maintenance are also highly valued, making it a top choice for those seeking both protection and temperature regulation.
Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector Full Size
While Protect-A-Bed offers fantastic options, sometimes a highly-rated, budget-friendly alternative hits the mark. The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector is a popular choice for its excellent balance of protection, comfort, and affordability. This protector offers a soft, blended surface that’s both absorbent and breathable, paired with a reliable TPU backing to prevent spills from reaching your mattress. It’s a great option if you need effective waterproofing and comfort without breaking the bank, especially for guest rooms or kids’ beds.
Key Features:
– Mattress Protector – Fits Full size mattress perfectly with dimensions 54 inches by 75 inches by 15 inches, featuring professionally turned hems and deep fitted pockets.
– Comfort Surface – Soft blended surface is extra absorbent, cozy and breathable. The specially designed waterproof top and high quality seam construction stops liquids from passing through.
– Fitted Style All Around Elastic – Mattress protector with a fitted style all round elastic band creates a secure fit on mattress depths.
– Waterproof Terry Top – The mattress protector protects your mattress from unwelcome spills and keeps your mattress clean and safe. High-quality TPU backing secures your mattress from the top and resists any leakage into the mattress.
– Care Instructions – Machine wash cold on gentle cycle; tumble dry low; do not iron; do not bleach; do not use fabric softener (packaging may slightly vary).
Pros:
– Very affordable and offers great value.
– Soft, absorbent, and breathable surface for comfort.
– Effective waterproof protection with a high-quality TPU backing.
– Secure fitted style with all-around elastic.
– Easy to care for and machine washable.
Cons:
– Not specifically designed for allergen or dust mite protection.
– May not offer the same level of advanced features (like cooling or antimicrobial) as premium options.
– Care instructions include avoiding fabric softener, which some might miss.
User Impressions:
Reviewers consistently praise the Utopia Bedding protector for its unbeatable value and reliable waterproofing. Many highlight its soft feel and quiet performance, especially given the price point. It’s frequently recommended as an excellent basic protector for everyday use, particularly for families with children or pets.
Conclusion
Choosing the right mattress protector is a simple yet effective way to safeguard your investment and enhance your sleep experience. Whether you prioritize ultimate allergen protection, a cool night’s sleep, luxurious comfort, or a budget-friendly shield, there’s a perfect match for you in our lineup. From the comprehensive 6-sided encasement to the advanced cooling charcoal options, Protect-A-Bed mattress protectors truly offer solutions for every need, proving why they’re a leading brand in bedding protection.
Remember, a clean mattress is a happy mattress, and a happy mattress means better sleep for you. Consider your specific needs—do you have allergies, do you sleep hot, or are spills your main concern?—and then choose the protector that best aligns with your lifestyle. Investing in one of these top-rated options will provide peace of mind and contribute significantly to a healthier, more comfortable sleeping environment for years to come.
FAQ Section
Q1: What’s the main difference between a mattress protector and a mattress pad?
A1: A mattress protector primarily focuses on protecting your mattress from spills, stains, allergens, and dust mites, often featuring a waterproof barrier. A mattress pad, on the other hand, is generally used to add extra comfort, cushioning, or softness to your bed, with less emphasis on protective features. Some modern protectors, however, offer both comfort and protection.
Q2: Are mattress protectors truly waterproof?
A2: Yes, high-quality mattress protectors like those from Protect-A-Bed use a waterproof membrane (like their Miracle Membrane) or a TPU backing to prevent liquids from reaching your mattress. It’s important to check the product description for “waterproof” rather than just “water-resistant” for full protection.
Q3: How often should I wash my mattress protector?
A3: For optimal hygiene, it’s generally recommended to wash your mattress protector every 1-2 months, or more frequently if there are spills, excessive sweating, or if you have allergies. Always follow the specific care instructions on the product label.
Q4: Will a mattress protector make my bed noisy or crinkly?
A4: Modern mattress protectors are designed to be soft, flexible, and quiet. While older or lower-quality protectors might have a crinkly sound, the options reviewed here, especially those with cotton-terry, TENCEL, or cooling fabrics, are typically noiseless and won’t affect the feel of your mattress.
Q5: Can mattress protectors help with allergies?
A5: Absolutely! Many mattress protectors, especially encasements, are designed to create a barrier against common allergens like dust mites, pet dander, and pollen. Look for terms like “hypoallergenic,” “allergen barrier,” or “dust mite proof” in the product description.
Q6: What’s the difference between a fitted-sheet style protector and an encasement?
A6: A fitted-sheet style protector covers the top and sides (5-sided) of your mattress, similar to how a fitted sheet works. An encasement, however, fully zips around your entire mattress, providing 6-sided protection against liquids, allergens, and even bed bugs, completely sealing off the mattress.
Q7: Are these protectors compatible with memory foam mattresses?
A7: Yes, most modern mattress protectors are designed to be compatible with all mattress types, including memory foam, latex, hybrid, and innerspring. Their flexible and thin designs ensure they won’t alter the unique feel or temperature regulation of your memory foam.
Q8: Can I use bleach on my mattress protector?
A8: It is strongly advised not to use bleach or bleach alternatives on most mattress protectors, especially those with waterproof membranes. Bleach can degrade the waterproof barrier, rendering it ineffective. Always check the specific care instructions for your protector.
Q9: Do mattress protectors help with cooling?
A9: Some mattress protectors, like the Cooling Charcoal Infused option reviewed, are specifically designed with cooling fibers or materials to help regulate temperature and keep you cool. If you’re a hot sleeper, look for features like “cooling,” “breathable,” or “TENCEL” fabrics.
